Field test · Plot. · 10 remote sessions
I made a chart styling tool for my own case studies. Then I watched 10 people make a chart with it.
I made the research charts in my case studies with Plot., so I never get lost in it. I wanted to see what happens when someone opens it cold, with real data and a real deadline in mind.
I recruited a mix on purpose: people who chart every day, people who design every day, and people who mostly use Canva or Google Slides. I treated their jobs as context, not as a guess about their skills.
The scenario: "You are preparing a small report and need a chart that tells a simple story. Make it presentation-ready and export it for another design tool." Everyone used the same data, five months of website visitors with a small dip in April.
I used neutral prompts like "What do you expect this to do?" and never pointed to a button. If someone needed a hint, the task counted as partial.
People out of 10 who completed each task on their own.
Task work took about 25 minutes on average. The data analyst finished in 19. The two slowest were undergrads who had only made charts in Google Sheets and Canva, at 31 and 32 minutes.
Everyone changed the colors and titles without help. One undergrad put it best: "I can make the chart look nicer than a default spreadsheet chart."
Two people pasted data in a format Plot. did not expect, and some picked the prettiest chart instead of the clearest one. "Once I found the data format, it made sense. A sample chart would help me start."
People were not sure which control changed the title, the axes, or all the text. Controls spread across panels made that worse.
All 10 found a way to start over, but most went looking for undo or reset first because they were scared to lose their chart.
Data and finance folks loved it for polish but will keep doing the math in Excel. That is fine. It tells me what Plot. should not try to be.
Everyone exported, but non-designers did not know when transparency was kept or why SVG helps in Figma.
Chart types are icons only. The data box is empty, with no example.
Plain-language hints on every chart type, and sample data you can paste over.
A short plain-language line and preview for each chart type.
Show an example dataset so people know what shape their data should be.
Put text, axes, legend, and grid controls under clear labels with live preview.
Visible undo, plus reset styling, so experimenting feels safe.
One line explaining PNG vs SVG, with a preview.
Save a palette and reuse it, without locking designers in.
Warn about low contrast and hard-to-read labels.
Next round: ship the P0 fixes, then retest with 6 people (some new, some returning), with extra focus on students and marketing folks who struggled most with starting.